Misconduct, incapacity, or poor performance? Getting it right in the workplace

Business, Human Resources

Author: Gerelene Chetty

Employers regularly face workplace challenges such as repeated errors, absenteeism, missed deadlines and failure to follow instructions. A common mistake is to treat every concern as misconduct. The key question is not only what went wrong, but why it happened. Correctly identifying the issue determines the appropriate process and helps prevent unfair dismissal disputes.

Three different workplace issues and the three different approaches

MISCONDUCT – This arises where an employee who is capable of complying, breaches a known and reasonable workplace rule or instruction. Examples include dishonesty, unauthorised absence, repeated lateness or deliberately refusing a lawful instruction. The employer should establish the rule, the employee’s knowledge, the breach, consistency and an appropriate sanction. Relevant cases: Sidumo v Rustenburg Platinum Mines Ltd (2008) 29 ILJ 2405 (CC), on the fairness and appropriateness of dismissal; and Avril Elizabeth Home v CCMA (2006) 27 ILJ 1644 (LC), on a fair non-criminal-style disciplinary process.

INCAPACITY – This concerns an employee’s inability to perform duties, for example because of illness, injury or dependency. An employee with recurring medically related absence should not automatically receive misconduct warnings. The employer should investigate the circumstances, consider medical information, reasonable adjustments, alternative work, counselling or rehabilitation where appropriate. Relevant cases: PSA obo Van Wyk v Department of Social Development [2025] ZALCCT 93, addressing alcoholism and incapacity; and Pahlanga v Petroleum Oil and Gas Corporation of SA [2021] ZALCCT 48 considering the distinction between alcohol-related misconduct and incapacity.

POOR PERFORMANCE – This arises where an employee does not meet the required work standard, despite being capable of doing so with appropriate instruction and support. For example, a payroll administrator repeatedly makes errors because they have not been adequately trained on a new system. Before taking action, the employer should clarify standards, identify the cause, provide guidance and training, set measurable improvement objectives and allow a reasonable opportunity to improve. Relevant cases: Somyo v Ross Poultry Breeders (Pty) Ltd (1997) 18 ILJ 1099 (LAC) and Palluci Home Depot (Pty) Ltd v Herskowitz (2015) 36 ILJ 1511 (LAC), on fair management of poor performance.

Why getting it wrong matters

Misclassifying a workplace problem can expose an employer to an unfair dismissal referral to the CCMA, arbitration, legal and HR costs, management time away from operations, potential reinstatement, re-employment or compensation orders. For example, dismissing an employee for poor performance without training or a fair opportunity to improve, or disciplining an employee for medically related absence without investigating incapacity, may undermine the fairness of the decision.

A practical HR process

Before issuing charges, warnings or making a dismissal decision, employers should:  establish the facts and underlying cause, identify whether the issue is misconduct, incapacity or poor performance, gather and retain relevant records, explain the concern and give the employee a fair opportunity to respond, provide support, training, counselling or explore alternatives where appropriate; and document the decision and reasons. Most importantly apply the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 and the Code of Good Practice.

The business takeaway

The cost of getting it wrong is not limited to a possible compensation payment. It includes management time, operational disruption, external advice and the loss of focus on running the business. These risks can be reduced through early HR involvement, accurate classification, proper documentation and a fair consistent process.

Previous Post
Employment Equity: Manage the Progress, Not Just the Report
Next Post
Excessive sick leave in South Africa: Should employers discipline or follow the incapacity process?

Related Posts