Excessive sick leave in South Africa: Should employers discipline or follow the incapacity process?

Business, Human Resources

Author: Vishanya Deeplall

An employee who is frequently absent from work due to illness can create significant operational challenges for an employer. Deadlines may be missed, workloads may shift to colleagues and productivity may suffer. But when an employee has taken what the employer considers to be “excessive” sick leave, an important question arises:

Should the employee be disciplined for excessive absenteeism, or should the employer follow an incapacity process?

The answer depends largely on why the employee is absent.

The financial impact of excessive sick leave should not be overlooked. Sick leave comes at a cost to employers, not only in terms of remuneration paid to employees who are absent and unable to perform their duties, but also through lost productivity, operational disruptions, overtime costs and the additional workload placed on other employees.

In South Africa, employers are required to provide paid sick leave in accordance with the Basic Conditions of Employment Act, which means that repeated absenteeism can have a significant financial impact on a business. However, this does not mean employers must simply accept excessive absenteeism without taking action. It can be managed, but it requires a proactive and legally compliant approach.

By monitoring absence patterns, addressing concerns early, engaging with employees and following the appropriate incapacity or disciplinary process, employers can protect their operational interests while ensuring that employees are treated fairly. The key is not to ignore the cost of absenteeism, but to manage it correctly.

South African labour law distinguishes between misconduct and incapacity due to ill health. Where an employee is genuinely unable to attend work because of illness or injury, the matter will generally need to be approached as one of incapacity rather than simply treating the absenteeism as misconduct.

The Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 (LRA), Schedule 8, Item 10 provides that incapacity due to ill health or injury may be temporary or permanent. Where an employee is temporarily unable to work, the employer should investigate the extent of the incapacity. If the absence is likely to be unreasonably long, the employer should consider alternatives short of dismissal, taking into account factors such as the nature of the job, the period of absence, the seriousness of the illness and the possibility of obtaining temporary replacement.

This does not mean, however, that an employee with frequent sick leave is automatically protected from disciplinary action.

There is an important distinction between being sick and abusing sick leave.

For example, an employee who repeatedly submits legitimate medical certificates and suffers from genuine medical conditions may present an incapacity issue. In contrast, an employee who deliberately misrepresents their illness, submits fraudulent documentation, fails to comply with reasonable reporting requirements or uses sick leave for purposes other than illness may potentially be dealing with misconduct.

The courts have recognised that persistent intermittent absenteeism can constitute incapacity, even where the employee’s individual periods of sick leave are genuine. In General Motors (Pty) Ltd v NUMSA obo Ruiters (2015), the Labour Appeal Court recognised excessive intermittent absence due to ill health as a form of incapacity and confirmed that an employer may, in appropriate circumstances, terminate employment on that basis after properly considering the requirements of the Code.

Similarly, in General Motors South Africa (Pty) Ltd v NUMSA and Others (2018), the Labour Court dealt with employees who had exceeded the employer’s sick-leave threshold and were subjected to incapacity enquiries. The Court recognised the employer’s right to address excessive sick absence through an incapacity process where the employee’s attendance was affecting their ability to fulfil their contractual obligations.

However, employers should be careful not to assume that a high number of sick-leave days automatically justifies dismissal. In Atlantis Foundries (Pty) Ltd v NUMSA obo Brown and Others (2020), the Labour Court considered frequent absenteeism for various illnesses but found the dismissal for incapacity premature because there was evidence suggesting a possible underlying cause that had not been sufficiently investigated.

The distinction becomes even more important where an employer suspects sick-leave abuse. In Cumaio v MEC Department (KZN) (2022), the Labour Court recognised the distinction between genuine incapacity and allegations that an employee had abused sick leave or engaged in malingering. Where the allegation is misconduct, a disciplinary process may be appropriate; where the issue is genuine ill health affecting the employee’s ability to work, an incapacity process should be considered.

More recently, SAMWU obo May v City of Cape Town Municipality (2026) illustrates the other side of the issue. The Court dealt with allegations of sick-leave dishonesty where an employee’s conduct while supposedly ill was inconsistent with the claimed incapacity. The case demonstrates that an employer may legitimately pursue a misconduct route where there is evidence suggesting dishonesty or abuse rather than merely frequent genuine illness.

For HR and managers, the practical lesson is therefore simple:

Do not discipline the absence simply because the absence is excessive. Investigate the reason for the absence first.

If the evidence indicates genuine ill health affecting the employee’s ability to render services, an incapacity process may be appropriate. If there is evidence of dishonesty, failure to follow reporting procedures or unauthorised absence, a disciplinary process may be appropriate.

The employer should also consider the employee’s medical circumstances, attendance history, job requirements, possible accommodation, previous interventions and whether the situation is likely to improve.

Ultimately, the number of sick-leave days is only the starting point, not the conclusion.

The better HR question is not:

“How many times has this employee been sick?”

It is:

“What is causing the absence, and what is the legally appropriate way to address it?”

Getting that distinction right can mean the difference between a fair, defensible HR process and a costly dispute.

Previous Post
Misconduct, incapacity, or poor performance? Getting it right in the workplace
Next Post
The December payroll crunch: Bonuses, early salaries, and no room for error

Related Posts